Essential stops for authentic NYC deli experiences
From pre–World War II icons like Katz's Delicatessen, B&H Dairy, and Sarge’s, to beloved local staples such as 2nd Ave Deli and Ben’s, and newcomers like Gertie, these essential New York delis are dishing out the best of the classic NYC experience—think matzah ball soup, golden knishes, stacked sandwiches, and of course, mile-high pastrami.
The soul of a true New York deli goes beyond just serving great food. The best establishments combine quality ingredients with tradition, atmosphere, and a certain unmistakable New York attitude. Whether it's the hand-carved technique at Katz's or the generations-old recipes at Barney Greengrass, these delis represent an important cultural tradition worth preserving.
While many excellent delis like Russ & Daughters and Liebman's didn't make our list, they're still worth visiting for anyone wanting to fully explore NYC's deli scene. Each neighborhood has its own local favorites, often with fiercely loyal customers who will defend their chosen deli's superiority.
This list is based on multiple visits to each establishment, and all meals were paid for by dothings.nyc (we don't accept free food or special treatment).
